By: Tom Cloyd
(Published: 2025-07-01; reviewed: 2025-07-01:1108 Pacific Time (USA))
Photo by Ioann-Mark Kuznietsov on Unsplash
(To stay focused on the main elements of this discussion, various technical considerations have been placed in the notes at the foot of this article. Access these notes to get a fuller discussion of what follows.)
That children respond in a wide variety of ways to their environment is not news. Often not considered, however, are two additional critical factors: their mother is their most important environment, prenatally, and usually after birth as well, and children themselves vary widely in how they react to just about anything.
So, consider now the picture this presents:
The question we take up here is to what degree, if any, a mother's having posttraumatic stress could affect a baby, in either of its two developmental environments.
To clarify and isolate the relationships of these factors, and to bring them all together into a cohesive whole, here is a chart specifying the system elements and relationships.2
"Panic attacks" are to be distinguished from panic disorders, which involve a cluster of symptoms that include panic attacks. Panic attacks are a brief, rapic-onset period of fear or anxiety which typically last a few minutes but can last longer. They can occur in the context of PTSD. ↩
The system portrayed is incomplete, as other non-specified factors are also involved. But, for purposes of this conceptualization these other factors are considered to be non-variant - i.e., constants. When working with actual research data, it is possible to achieve this through the design of the research (which may eliminate some of these factors) or through statistical manipulations (which isolate their influence, then remove it mathematically from the system). ↩
Apparently, she did not get treatment for her PTSD (at that time, in the late 20th century, many people thought it was a permanent condition). Validated treatments such as EMDR were not well known, even among professional psychologists. ↩
☀ ☀ ☀